3DEXPERIENCE SOLIDWORKS vs. OnShape
In the realm of CAD software, choosing the right platform can significantly impact design and engineering workflows. Two softwares in this space are 3DEXPERIENCE SOLIDWORKS and OnShape. In this article, we'll explore the features, performance, integration, support, pricing, licensing models, upgrades, additional tools, and collaborative capabilities of both platforms, providing valuable insights to help you make an informed decision.
Interface and Capabilities:
3DEXPERIENCE SOLIDWORKS offers a user-friendly interface that closely resembles traditional SOLIDWORKS, making it easy for users to navigate and utilize familiar tools. Its extensive suite of capabilities includes advanced simulation tools, structural analysis, fluid dynamics, and kinematics, empowering users to tackle complex design challenges with ease.
Along with 3DEXPERIENCE SOLIDWORKS, OnShape also offers a streamlined user interface with intuitive tools and features. While its interface may not be as extensive as 3DEXPERIENCE SOLIDWORKS, it provides a user-friendly environment for design and collaboration.
Licensing:
3DEXPERIENCE SOLIDWORKS follows a Named User licensing model, requiring internet access for software usage. There is an option to work offline without connecting to the 3DEXPERIENCE platform using the "Work Offline" command. This offline capability allows for a maximum consecutive offline period of 30 days. Should you exceed this timeframe without reconnecting online, your applications will automatically connect at which point you can verify licensing and move back to offline mode if needed.
Named user licenses are a licensing model where each user is assigned a unique login and password. This allows users to access the software from any internet-connected device, including mobile devices. The named user system streamlines access by eliminating the need for physical or machine-specific licenses, making it easier for users to log in and access the software from wherever they are. It's important to highlight that 3DEXPERIENCE SOLIDWORKS functions on a leasing basis, which gives you access to the latest updates and flexibility to scale up or down your usages quarterly or yearly.
Similarly, OnShape utilizes a cloud-based licensing model, mandating continuous internet connectivity for software utilization. There is no offline capability available with OnShape. OnShape is only sold on a subscription basis.
Upgrades:
As a software-as-a-service (SaaS) platform, 3DEXPERIENCE SOLIDWORKS provides automatic service pack updates four times a year. There are hot fixes that are immediately pushed upon availability as needed throughout the year as well.
OnShape also offers regular updates and improvements, similar to 3DEXPERIENCE SOLIDWORKS.
Integration and Support:
Integration and support are essential factors to consider when evaluating CAD software. 3DEXPERIENCE SOLIDWORKS has seamless integration with other software solutions, such as:
These integrations enabe users to leverage a comprehensive ecosystem of tools and resources.
Additionally, SOLIDWORKS offers extensive support options, including a network of resellers and a vibrant community, providing users with access to comprehensive training and troubleshooting resources.
OnShape, while lacking the extensive support network of SOLIDWORKS, provides online support and collaboration features, catering to the needs of users seeking a cloud-based CAD solution.
Additional & Included Browser-based Tools:
3DEXPERIENCE SOLIDWORKS offers a range of additional browser-based tools, including:
These tools enhance collaboration and productivity, enabling users to work seamlessly across platforms and devices. Collaborative Industry Innovator and 3DSwymer facilitate real-time collaboration and cloud storage, allowing multiple users to work on projects simultaneously.
While OnShape provides a robust set of design and collaboration tools, it may not offer the same level of integration and ecosystem as 3DEXPERIENCE SOLIDWORKS though. OnShape is popular with students and startups, but as businesses grow, they find its features limiting. That's where 3DEXPERIENCE SOLIDWORKS comes in. It offers advanced capabilities for scaling enterprises, unlocking endless possibilities for innovation and success.
Data Security:
Security measures for 3DEXPERIENCE include filtering internet traffic to ensure only intended traffic, providing each organization with its own cloud instance to partition data from other organizations, implementing double peer-reviewed application code aligned with industry best practices, conducting maintenance such as system patching and continuous scans to monitor security, and storing data in secure data centers limited to authorized personnel, with redundant disks, disaster recovery, and backup procedures in place.
3DEXPERIENCE also has extensive permission-based settings for admins to allow data to only be seen or edited by intended users. The share and markup cabilities further enable data sharing to non-CAD users through a browser-based viewer accessible only to the intended viewer.
OnShape provides precise sharing options for documents, including "Edit" and "View only" permissions. While encryption is enforced, users should exercise caution when sharing sensitive data. All communications are encrypted, and passwords are securely hashed. Ongoing security testing ensures the platform's resilience against vulnerabilities. Users can report security issues to OnShape for prompt resolution.
2 Scenarios Examples Where 3DEXPERIENCE SOLIDWORKS Would Be the Better Option:
1. Scalability for a Quickly Growing Business:
An engineering company experiencing rapid growth needs a CAD solution that can handle increasing project demands. Choosing 3DEXPERIENCE SOLIDWORKS, they take advantage of its industry-standard status and cloud-based infrastructure to seamlessly scale operations. Its integrated collaboration tools ensure efficient communication and project management across distributed teams, supporting the company's expansion efforts effectively.
2. Seamlessly Recruiting and Training new Employees:
A manufacturing company looking to grow its engineering team is looking for a CAD solution that new employees can pick up quickly. Choosing 3DEXPERIENCE SOLIDWORKS, its industry-standard status and comprehensive training tools, guarantee a smooth onboarding process. With its familiar interface and effective training programs, new recruits can confidently contribute to projects from day one, accelerating the company's growth path.
Bottom Line:
Both 3DEXPERIENCE SOLIDWORKS and OnShape offer compelling features and capabilities for design and engineering. 3DEXPERIENCE SOLIDWORKS has an edge in terms of integration, simulation capabilities, and automatic updates. Ultimately, the choice between the two platforms depends on your specific requirements, workflow preferences, and budgetary considerations. Whether you prioritize seamless collaboration, advanced simulation tools, or user-friendly design, both 3DEXPERIENCE SOLIDWORKS and OnShape have much to offer.